The Rumour Mill

102-1 Main St, Phelps, NY 14532, United States
+1 315-719-2631
$$$ Cafe
(36 Reviews)
Price Range $1–10

Welcome to The Rumour Mill, a delightful café nestled in the heart of Phelps, NY. Located at 102-1 Main St, this charming spot is more than just a coffee shop; it's a community hub where artistry and passion intertwine. Owned and operated by the dynamic duo, Seth and Nathan, The Rumour Mill exudes warmth and a welcoming atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home.

As you step through the front door, or even the quaint back entrance from the parking lot, you're greeted with the rich, intoxicating aroma of expertly brewed coffee. The menu features a variety of enticing hot beverages, including the soothing Hot Chocolate ($5.05), comforting Hot Chai Latte ($6.05), and their fan-favorite Hot Latte ($5.55). For those looking for a caffeine kick, the robust Espresso ($3.55) is a must-try, showcasing the café's dedication to top-tier coffee that even seasoned aficionados would rave about.

More than just java, The Rumour Mill also offers a selection of scrumptious baked goods. Imagine sinking your teeth into a freshly made Blueberry Muffin ($4.00) or indulging in a rich Chocolate Chip Muffin ($4.00) while sipping on your drink of choice. The Strawberry Danish ($4.00) is another delectable option that perfectly pairs with any of their brewed coffees, elevating your café experience to new heights.

What truly sets The Rumour Mill apart, however, is its ambiance. Picture yourself in a cozy nook, surrounded by friendly patrons and laughter echoing off the walls. The café's decor is a reflection of Seth and Nathan's creativity, making it an inviting space to unwind or catch up with friends. As Shanty Hawke poignantly observed, it's not just a coffee shop; it's a reflection of passion, love, and community spirit. Customers such as Nina TS have remarked on the personable nature of the owners, further emphasizing the café's inviting environment.

With monthly drink specials that keep things fresh and exciting, it's no wonder customers rave about their experiences at The Rumour Mill. Emily Bryant highlighted their delicious Chai Tea Latte as the best she had ever tasted, while Laura expressed her delight upon discovering their seasonal lattes, such as the pumpkin edition.

If you're in the Phelps area, make it a point to visit The Rumour Mill. Whether you're seeking a cozy spot to enjoy a breakfast sandwich, catch up on work, or indulge in a sweet treat, this café has something for everyone. Bring your friends, or simply take a moment for yourself—it’s the perfect getaway where delicious coffee and heartfelt service intertwine.

For those who frequent the café, it becomes a cherished part of their daily routine, as noted by Kent Graham, who appreciates the fantastic atmosphere and top-notch coffee. The Rumour Mill isn’t just a place to grab a drink; it's a warm corner of Phelps where community thrives and friendships blossom. Be sure to stop by and find out why it's rapidly becoming the beloved gathering spot for locals and visitors alike.

Service options
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Great coffee
Popular for
Breakfast
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Offerings
Coffee
Quick bite
Dining options
Breakfast
Dessert
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Quiet
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Parking
Openings Hours
Checking

Monday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Tuesday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Wednesday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Thursday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Friday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Saturday

08:00 AM - 02:00 PM

Sunday

08:00 AM - 01:00 PM

36 Reviews
Ella Bella

22 Sep 2025

Seth and Nathan are by far my favorite people. They are so inviting and nice and absolutely hilarious. They always know what I want before I order and when my boyfriend doesn't know what he wants, they always have the perfect suggestion. Not to mention, the drinks and breakfast sandwiches are always phenomenal.

Kent Graham

04 Sep 2025

Coffee is Spot on. Breakfast was great. The atmosphere is beyond cozy and friendly. The owners and Staff are absolutely amazing.

Shanty Hawke

28 Aug 2025

I've been lucky enough to watch two amazing friends turn their dream into something truly special. From the very first visit, it's clear this place is more than just a coffee shop—it's a reflection of their passion, creativity, and love for community. The coffee? Absolutely top-tier. Every cup is crafted with care, and you can taste the difference. The atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and beautifully designed. What truly sets them apart is how they engage with their customers. They’re not just serving coffee—they're building relationships, sparking conversations, and creating a space that people genuinely want to return to. I’m incredibly proud of what they’ve built. This shop isn’t just about caffeine—it’s about connection, creativity, and community. If you haven’t visited yet, you’re missing out on something special.

Nina TS

04 Aug 2025

My wife and I stopped in to kick off our Saturday errand day. They have a front door on Main St and the backdoor is in the parking lot on Exchange St. There were a few people sitting at the bar, chatting and having a grand time. Upon arrival, there was a couple in front of us, and another couple came in shortly after us. The owners are very personable, friendly, and respectful. There is a chill vibe the moment you walk in. There are a few tables, chairs and a settee in there for customers to relax. I ordered a Matcha Latte. My spouse ordered a fancy Coffee with flavor. They were absolutely delicious. I'll definitely be back. I'm so excited my hometown has an official coffee shop!

Taylor Polmanteer

09 Jul 2025

Perks of living in the village? A nice walk away from some delicious coffee (much needed after a long night with the baby.) The Rumor Mill has been a wonderful addition to Phelps. Really cool and chill place to go check out! Food is great too.

Emily Bryant

05 Jul 2025

Wonderful addition to downtown Phelps. Cozy environment with welcoming staff. Monthly drink specials that are all delicious. Best Chai Tea Latte I have ever had . I cannot recommend this shop enough!

Alex Schreck

24 Jun 2025

Went for the first time today for a little pick me up. I got the Maple Wave and it was by far the best coffee I’ve had in a really long time. The place is gorgeous plenty of sitting room, and the guys behind the counter were really nice! I will absolutely be back.

Laura

03 Jun 2025

Friday was my first time trying their lattes, and it didn't disappoint. I've been in the mood for a pumpkin latte lately and I was very happy to see that they had specialty lattes featuring one. I also purchased a frozen cookies and cream with espresso and a caramel iced coffee for some coworkers. Both enjoyed their drinks. I didn't get a chance to have any food but I will definitely be back.

Checking
Listing Image

Prandium Cortland

185 Homer Ave, Cortland, NY 13045, United States
Cafe
(98 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Terra Bona Bakery Cafe

126 W 11th St, Goodland, KS 67735, United States
Cafe
(49 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Mocha Town

159 University Ave, Newark, NJ 07102, United States
Cafe
(66 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Break del Borgo - Peraga

Via Nazionale, 9, 10010 Mercenasco TO, Italy
Cafeteria
(120 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Cosmic Cafe

1300 S Lake Shore Dr, Chicago, IL 60605, United States
Cafe
(134 Reviews)

Join the The Rumour Mill Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.