The Rumour Mill Menu

Welcome to The Rumour Mill, a delightful café nestled in Phelps, NY, where community and quality meld seamlessly. Here, every item on the menu is a testament to the owners' passion for coffee and connection. Start your day with a satisfying Hot Latte or indulge in a rich Hot Chocolate, both crafted to perfection for just over five dollars. Craving something sweet? The freshly baked Strawberry Danish or a delicious Chocolate Chip Muffin makes for a perfect companion.

Patrons rave about the cozy atmosphere and friendly service, with owners Seth and Nathan ensuring each visit feels personal. From expertly brewed espressos to their exceptional breakfast sandwiches, every bite and sip reflects a commitment to excellence. Whether grabbing a quick cup or settling in for a leisurely chat, The Rumour Mill embodies what a café should be—a charming space filled with warmth, laughter, and fantastic food.

Blended

• Frozen Vanilla Chai

  US$6.00

• Frozen Coffee

  US$6.00

• Frozen Cookies & Cream

  US$6.00

Food

• Bacon Egg & Cheese

  US$5.95

• Sausage Egg And Cheese

  Sausage Egg and Cheese

  US$6.25

• Everything Bagel

  US$3.45

• Three Cheese Egg Bites

  US$5.90

• Bacon Cheese Egg Bites

  US$5.90

• Plain Bagel

  US$3.45

• Sausage Cheese Egg Bites

  US$5.90

Hot

• Hot Chocolate

  US$5.05

• Hot Latte

  US$5.55

• Hot Macchiato

  US$6.05

• Espresso

  US$3.55

• Steamer

  US$4.55

• Brewed Tea

  US$4.25

• Hot White Mocha

  US$6.55

• Hot Matcha Latte

  US$6.05

• Hot Americano

  US$4.95

• Hot Cappuccino

  US$5.55

• Brewed Coffee

  US$3.55

• Hot Mocha

  US$6.25

• Hot Chai Latte

  US$6.05

Bakery

• Strawberry Danish

  US$4.00

• Cut Out Cookie

  US$4.00

• Blueberry Muffin

  US$4.00

• Lemon Poppy Seed

  US$4.00

• Chocolate Chip Muffin

  US$4.00

Bottles

• Apple Juice

  US$2.00

• Orange Juice

  US$2.00

Shaken Espresso

• Brown Sugar Oat Milk

  US$7.05

• The OG

  US$6.05

Cold

• Macchiato

  US$6.25

• Cappuccino

  US$5.55

• Iced Green Tea

  US$4.25

• Iced Black Tea

  US$4.25

• Iced Coffee

  US$4.05

• Barista Special

  US$6.05

• Mocha

  US$6.80

• Strawberry Açaí Refresher

  US$6.05

• Latte

  US$5.80

• Americano

  US$4.85

• Cold Brew

  US$5.15

• Chai Latte

  US$6.15

• White Mocha

  US$6.80

• Matcha Latte

  US$6.25